iven the centrality of Vienna in the musical history
of the last two and a half centuries, programming a concert series with
Austria as its focus is not exactly heavy lifting. Still, the Austrian
Cultural Forum has been offering inventive programs of old and new music
since it opened its sleek, intimate chamber music hall a few seasons ago,
and it has made an annual series of thoughtful, focused vocal recitals a
part of its mission.
This year the series is devoted to Mahler, a logical enough choice
given his way with a vocal line, particularly when the text is either
sublimely innocent, wrenchingly emotional or just plain morbid. Thomas
Bagwell, an assistant conductor at the Metropolitan Opera and the director
and pianist of the forum's vocal series, selected works that touch on all
those qualities for the first installment, on Tuesday evening.
The first half of the program, in which Mr. Bagwell accompanied Meagan
Miller, a soprano, offered some of Mahler's "Knaben Wunderhorn" settings,
which range from the fanciful and wryly amusing ("Lob des hohen
Verstandes," about a singing contest between a nightingale and a cuckoo,
judged by a donkey) to the hopeless ("Der Tamboursg'sell," about a
military drummer about to be hanged). After the intermission, Robert
Gardner, a baritone, took up "Kindertotenlieder," Mahler's reflection (by
way of Friedrich Rückert's poetry) on children's deaths.
"Kindertotenlieder" and most of the "Knaben Wunderhorn" selections are
best known as orchestral songs. Mr. Bagwell's argument is that when heard
in a simpler context, with just voice and piano, the texts come through
more powerfully. It's a dubious argument: given Mahler's ear for the
subtleties of instrumental color, and his penchant for orchestrational
lushness, this clarity comes at a significant cost.
But there were moments when Mr. Bagwell's argument seemed to have
merit. In the five "Kindertotenlieder" songs, Mr. Gardner offset the
music's broader gestures with a measure of delicacy that would be
difficult to produce in an orchestral context. Ms. Miller, too, used the
intimacy of the setting to create finely calibrated characterizations.
Both singers are young and have attractive voices, and both sing with a
keen awareness of the text, which was clearly central to Mr. Bagwell's
project. And Mr. Bagwell's nicely shaded playing allowed the singers ample
room to move, interpretively speaking.
The program is repeated tonight. The remaining concerts in the
Mahler series at the Austrian Cultural Forum, 11 East 52nd Street, are on
March 1 and 3 and May 8 and 10. (212)
319-5300.